1) Janab Ashraf Ali
thanvi
shahib Farmatay hain:'
meray dil mein Ahmad
Raza k liye bai hadh Ihtram
hai ,wo Humain Kafir
kehta hai,Laikin Ishq-e-
Rasool(aslato-a
ssalaam)
kie bana per kehta hai kise aur garz se tou
nahi
kehta''
Chiitah Lahore 23 April
1926
. . . . . . . . 2) Khurasheed Ali Khan
S.D.O(naher) kehtay
hain
k:- Molana Amhmad
Raza
khan brelvi kay intaqal per breli se Hazrat
Thanvi
kay aik murred ka Tar
(letter) aya,jou mein
nai
per kar sunaya, hazrat thnavi nai. (Inelha wo
inalha rajeoin), peri
hazrien mein se kise
nai
kaha k Molana Ahmad
0brelvi nai ap ko Kafir kaaha ar ap iun k maut
per inhila per rahay
hain,Hazrat Thanvi nai
Farmaya''Molvie
Ahmad
Raza khan baray Alim aur
Ishq-e-Rasool(a
ssalto-
asalaam) mein
dhoobay
howay thay. Iunho nai meri
ibarat ka jou matlab
samja
aur iuse k bina per ju
likha wo sahi tha. Aur
ager mein in ki jaga hota
aur
wo meri jga hotay,aur
iun
ki kalam se yeh Alfaz
sarzad hotay,tou ise matlab ki bana per w
jou
samjay thay,mein iun k
takfir hi karta. (Molana
Kosar shafi Niazi nai b
Mufti Muhammad shafi Shahib DEo Bandi ki
zubani
suna howa yehi
wakiya,Apnay Kalam''
Mushatad-o-
Tasarat''(Rozna ma Jang)mein tehreer
kiya)
. . . . . . . .
3) Abu Al-Ali Modvi
shahib
Farmatay hain:-''Moalna
Ahmad Raza khan
shahib
Ilim-o-Fazal ka mere
dil
mein bara ihtram hai,Fi-
alwaka wo uloom-o-
deeni
per bari nazer rakhtay
hain,aur iun ki fazeelat
ka aitraf iun logo ko b
hai,jou iun se ihtilaaf
rakhte hain,nazie
mobhasat ki waja se
jou
Talhiya paida hui hain,darasal iun k ilmi
kamalat,aur deeni
khidmat
per perda dalnay ki
mojab
hui''( hafta Roza shahab
Lahore,25 november
1926)
. . . . . . . .
4) anab syed
Sulemman Nadvi shahib Farmtay
hain;-ise Ahkar nai
Janab
Molana Ahmad Raza
khan
brelvi (Marhoom) ki chand
Kitabien dekhie,tou
meri
ankhie hairan(surpise) ho kar reh gie,hairan
(surprise) tha k yeh
wakiye . Moalana
Ahmad
Raza khan shahib kie
hain,Jin k mutaliq kal tak
yeh suna tha,k wo sirf
ahle-Bidat ki tarjmaan
hain, aur sirf chand
frohi
masZ NAHI.yeh Ahle-Bidat k Naqeeb
nahi
bal k yeh tou alm-e-
Islam
k scholar and shahkar
nazaer atay hain,jis tara
Molana Ahmad Raza ki
tehreero mein gehri
pai
jati hai,ise tara gehri
tou mera ustaad-e
mukram,
(jinad molana shibli
nomani,aur hazat
Hakeem
Molana Ashraf Ali Thanvi,
aur molana Mehmoond
Al-
hassan deo bandi aur
hazrat Molana shykh ul
Tafseer Allama shahbir Ahmad Usmani k
ANDER B
NAHI HAI,jis Qader
Molana
Amhad Raza khan ki
tehriroo mein hai''( Mahmana
'Nadoo'August 1913
page
17 )
. . . . . . . .
5)''Seerat Ul Nabi''k naam
ki mashoor kitab
likhnay
walay. Janab Shimbli
Noumani shahib
farmtay haim:-"Molvi Amhad
khan
Raza shahib jou apnay
Aqeed mein sahat
Tasdad
hain,mager ise k bawajood
Molana Amhad Raza
shahib
ka ilmi-e-Shajar ise
Qader
buland darjay ka hai, k iuse dor k tamama
Aalm-
e-deen Molana Amhad
Raza
khan shahib k samnay
pirka ki b haisiat nahi rakhte, ise Aqar nai b
ap
Ahmad Raza ki
kiatabien
parien,jis mein Aikam-
e- Shariat aur deegar
Kitabien b shamil hain,
aur
naiz yeh k.. Molanaa ki
sarprasti per aik
Mahanama Risala''Al Raza''
breli se niklta hai,jis k
chand Qistien Bagoro-
Hoz
dekhie hain,jis mein
Buland paya Mozameen shaya
hotay hain''Reesala
"Nadoo"October 1924
page
17)
6) Mashoor siaysi aur Mazhabi Leader Molana
Muhammad Ali Johar
Farmatay hain :-''iuse
dor
k Mashooor Alme-deen
Moalana Ahmad Raza khan
brelvi wakiye aik
Azeem
Muslam rehnama
hain,hum
baz batoo ki ikhitalaf k bawajood iun ki
Azeem
shakhsiyat, aur deeni
rehnama honay k
aitraf
ise liye kartay hain k wo
iuse dor k . sub se
baray
Mohaqaq,musanaf
,adeeb,sha
aur MARDE_HAQ thay, bila
shuba asie hastiyo ka
wajod-e-masoood
humray
liye Marhoon-e-minat
hai.''(roznama khilafat Mumbai Page 4)
. . . . . . . .
7) Janab Anwar
Kashmri
(sadar madras
Darulloom deo Band) Farmtay
hain:-
Jub banda Tirmizi
Shareef
aur deegar Kutab-e-
Hadees ki shaouro Likh raha tha,tou Bisab-e-
Zorert Ahadees ki
jazeeiat
dekhnay ki zorert paid
ie..
tou meinn nai shia, hazrat
ahlay Hadees aur ahlay
deoband hazrat kie
kitabien dekhie mader
zaihen Mutmin na
howa,Bik akhir aik dost ki
mashwaray se Molana
Ahamd Raza khan ki
kitabien dekhie tou
mera
dil mutmin hogoya tou mein ab bahobi
ahadees ki
sharoue bila jijhak likh
sakta hoon,wakiya
brelvi
hazrat k serkarda Alim Molana Ahmad RAza
khan
shahib ki tehrrieen
shistaaur mazboot
hain,jisay dekh kar yeh
andaza hota hai, k yeh Molvi Ahmad RAza
khan
shahib aik zabardast
Alim-
e-deen aur fikiya hain''
Mahnama Hadi,deoband,
Jamadil Awal 1330
hijri,page 21)
Darulloom deoband ki
shiekh Al Adaab, Jinab
Izaaz Ali Farmtay hain :-
yeh Ahqar yeh baat
tasleem karnay per
majoor
hai k,ise door ander
ager mohqaq aur alm-e-
deen
hai tou wo Molana
Ahmad
Raza khan shahib hain
q k mein nai Molana
Ahmad
Raza khan ko , jisay
hum
aj tak,kafir,mushr ik bidati
kehtay rahay hain,
buhat
wasiee ul nazar aur
buland
kahyal iloo himat alam-e-
deen shahib e fikro
nazar
paya hai, Ap Ahmad
Raza k
daliel Quran-o-sunat se mutsadim nahi, bal kay
am
ahang hain,lihaza mein
ap
ko mashwara
doonga,ager ap ko kise mushkal
maslay
mein,ager ap ko kise
masalay mein kise
kisamki
uljaan dar paish ho,tou ap
breli mein jakar,
Molana
Ahmad Raza khan
shahbi
brelvi se tehqeeq karien''( Reesala Al-
Noor,thana bhoon,
Shawal
al Mukram, 1346 hijri
page
40) . . . . . . .
9) Justice Malik Ghulam
Ali
Shahib farmtay hain:-
Haqeeqt yeh hai k
Molana Ahmad Raza khan
shahib k
barien mein ab tak
hum log
shaht Galt fehmi mein
mubtala thay.iun k baz tasanief aur fatwa k
matalia k bad,ise
natiija
per pohncha hoon,'jou
ilmi
gehri mein iun ki yaha paii
wo buhat kam logo
mein
pai jati hain''aur Ishq-
e-
Khuda aur Rasool (assalato-assal am) iun ki
satar satar se phoot
parta
hai (Aramgani Haram
Page
14 Lakhnuw) . . . . . . .
10) Janab Moen ul deen
Nadwi farmtay hain :-''
Molana Ahmad Raza
khan
shahib brelvi iuse door k
shahib-e-ilem o nazar
ulma musanfeen mein
se
thay, deeni Hasoosan
Fika o Hadees per iun ki
nazar
qasiee aur gehri thie,
Molana Ahmad raza jis
waqt nazr aur tehqeeq
k sath ulma k istafraat k
jawab tehreer farmay
hain, iuse se iun k
jamiyat,ilmi
biseerat ,deeyanat aur
tabie ka pura pura andaza
hota hai,iun k alamana
mehkana fatway
Mohalfat
o Moofaq her Tabka k
Mootlia k lain hain Mahnama Mohraf,
Azam
Garh Shumra
September
1949)
. . . . . . . 11) Jinab Shahbir
Ahmad
Usmani Farmatay
hain :-
Molana Ahamd Raza
khan ko Takfir k jurm mein
Bura
kehna buhat hi bura
hai
hai, q k wo buhat
baray Alam-e-deen aur
Buland
paya k Muhaqiq thay,
Molana Ahmad Raza
khan ki
Rihalat Alam-e-Islam ka
buhat bara saniha
hai,jise
nazar andaz nahi kiya
ja
sakta''( Ma Hadi Deoband
Zul haja 1369 hijri
page 21)
. . . . . . .
12) Jinab Muhammad
Yousaf Banoori k walid shahib
Zakira shah Banori
Farmatay hain:-''Ager
Allah Talla Hindustan
mein
Molana Ahmad Raza khan
brelvi ko paida na
farmatay tou
hindustaan
mein Hanfiyat Hatem
hojati'' . . . . . . .
13) Jinad Abu Al
Hassan Ali
Nadvi Farmatay hain:-
Fika
Hanfi aur iuse ki Jaziat per jou, Molana Ahmad
Raza khan ko aboor
hasil
tha, ise Zamamne mein
iuse ki Nazer nahi milti
14) Modvi Jammat ka Mashoor sahafo Janab
Manoor Al haq farmtay
hain :- Jub hum Imam
Ahmad Raza khan fazle
Brelvi ki kitabo ka
matalia kartay hain tou,tou
masool
hota hai k yeh shakhs
apni
ilmi Fazelat aur apni
abkiriyat ki waja se doosray ulma per
akaila hi
barie hai''(Mahanama
hijaz-e-jadeed , New
Dehli
januray 1989 page 84) . . . . . . .
15) Molana Hiyaat
Muhammad Kosar
Niazi
Farmtay hain :- Molana
Ahmad Raza khan Brelvi k
barien mein ula
deoband k
biynaat per mushtamil
mazmoon ise
Haqeeqat ka aitraaf hai k, Aala
Hazrat
Ahmad raza Brelvi
bilashuba sachay Ashq-
e-
Rasool(assalato - assalaam
aur deen k Yagaana
rozgar
Alam-e aur milat ki
Mohsin
thay''(Roznama JUNG Lahore 3 October
1990 )
. . . . . . .
16) Janab Dr. Israr
Ahmad
(bani tanzeem-e- islam i) Farmatay hain:-''Imam
Ahmad Raza khan
Peechli
sadi ki Mujdeed thay
aur
iun k ilam mein koi shak
nahi''(24 october 2004,
Sialkot Anwar Club
(Confernce 2004)
thanvi
shahib Farmatay hain:'
meray dil mein Ahmad
Raza k liye bai hadh Ihtram
hai ,wo Humain Kafir
kehta hai,Laikin Ishq-e-
Rasool(aslato-a
ssalaam)
kie bana per kehta hai kise aur garz se tou
nahi
kehta''
Chiitah Lahore 23 April
1926
. . . . . . . . 2) Khurasheed Ali Khan
S.D.O(naher) kehtay
hain
k:- Molana Amhmad
Raza
khan brelvi kay intaqal per breli se Hazrat
Thanvi
kay aik murred ka Tar
(letter) aya,jou mein
nai
per kar sunaya, hazrat thnavi nai. (Inelha wo
inalha rajeoin), peri
hazrien mein se kise
nai
kaha k Molana Ahmad
0brelvi nai ap ko Kafir kaaha ar ap iun k maut
per inhila per rahay
hain,Hazrat Thanvi nai
Farmaya''Molvie
Ahmad
Raza khan baray Alim aur
Ishq-e-Rasool(a
ssalto-
asalaam) mein
dhoobay
howay thay. Iunho nai meri
ibarat ka jou matlab
samja
aur iuse k bina per ju
likha wo sahi tha. Aur
ager mein in ki jaga hota
aur
wo meri jga hotay,aur
iun
ki kalam se yeh Alfaz
sarzad hotay,tou ise matlab ki bana per w
jou
samjay thay,mein iun k
takfir hi karta. (Molana
Kosar shafi Niazi nai b
Mufti Muhammad shafi Shahib DEo Bandi ki
zubani
suna howa yehi
wakiya,Apnay Kalam''
Mushatad-o-
Tasarat''(Rozna ma Jang)mein tehreer
kiya)
. . . . . . . .
3) Abu Al-Ali Modvi
shahib
Farmatay hain:-''Moalna
Ahmad Raza khan
shahib
Ilim-o-Fazal ka mere
dil
mein bara ihtram hai,Fi-
alwaka wo uloom-o-
deeni
per bari nazer rakhtay
hain,aur iun ki fazeelat
ka aitraf iun logo ko b
hai,jou iun se ihtilaaf
rakhte hain,nazie
mobhasat ki waja se
jou
Talhiya paida hui hain,darasal iun k ilmi
kamalat,aur deeni
khidmat
per perda dalnay ki
mojab
hui''( hafta Roza shahab
Lahore,25 november
1926)
. . . . . . . .
4) anab syed
Sulemman Nadvi shahib Farmtay
hain;-ise Ahkar nai
Janab
Molana Ahmad Raza
khan
brelvi (Marhoom) ki chand
Kitabien dekhie,tou
meri
ankhie hairan(surpise) ho kar reh gie,hairan
(surprise) tha k yeh
wakiye . Moalana
Ahmad
Raza khan shahib kie
hain,Jin k mutaliq kal tak
yeh suna tha,k wo sirf
ahle-Bidat ki tarjmaan
hain, aur sirf chand
frohi
masZ NAHI.yeh Ahle-Bidat k Naqeeb
nahi
bal k yeh tou alm-e-
Islam
k scholar and shahkar
nazaer atay hain,jis tara
Molana Ahmad Raza ki
tehreero mein gehri
pai
jati hai,ise tara gehri
tou mera ustaad-e
mukram,
(jinad molana shibli
nomani,aur hazat
Hakeem
Molana Ashraf Ali Thanvi,
aur molana Mehmoond
Al-
hassan deo bandi aur
hazrat Molana shykh ul
Tafseer Allama shahbir Ahmad Usmani k
ANDER B
NAHI HAI,jis Qader
Molana
Amhad Raza khan ki
tehriroo mein hai''( Mahmana
'Nadoo'August 1913
page
17 )
. . . . . . . .
5)''Seerat Ul Nabi''k naam
ki mashoor kitab
likhnay
walay. Janab Shimbli
Noumani shahib
farmtay haim:-"Molvi Amhad
khan
Raza shahib jou apnay
Aqeed mein sahat
Tasdad
hain,mager ise k bawajood
Molana Amhad Raza
shahib
ka ilmi-e-Shajar ise
Qader
buland darjay ka hai, k iuse dor k tamama
Aalm-
e-deen Molana Amhad
Raza
khan shahib k samnay
pirka ki b haisiat nahi rakhte, ise Aqar nai b
ap
Ahmad Raza ki
kiatabien
parien,jis mein Aikam-
e- Shariat aur deegar
Kitabien b shamil hain,
aur
naiz yeh k.. Molanaa ki
sarprasti per aik
Mahanama Risala''Al Raza''
breli se niklta hai,jis k
chand Qistien Bagoro-
Hoz
dekhie hain,jis mein
Buland paya Mozameen shaya
hotay hain''Reesala
"Nadoo"October 1924
page
17)
6) Mashoor siaysi aur Mazhabi Leader Molana
Muhammad Ali Johar
Farmatay hain :-''iuse
dor
k Mashooor Alme-deen
Moalana Ahmad Raza khan
brelvi wakiye aik
Azeem
Muslam rehnama
hain,hum
baz batoo ki ikhitalaf k bawajood iun ki
Azeem
shakhsiyat, aur deeni
rehnama honay k
aitraf
ise liye kartay hain k wo
iuse dor k . sub se
baray
Mohaqaq,musanaf
,adeeb,sha
aur MARDE_HAQ thay, bila
shuba asie hastiyo ka
wajod-e-masoood
humray
liye Marhoon-e-minat
hai.''(roznama khilafat Mumbai Page 4)
. . . . . . . .
7) Janab Anwar
Kashmri
(sadar madras
Darulloom deo Band) Farmtay
hain:-
Jub banda Tirmizi
Shareef
aur deegar Kutab-e-
Hadees ki shaouro Likh raha tha,tou Bisab-e-
Zorert Ahadees ki
jazeeiat
dekhnay ki zorert paid
ie..
tou meinn nai shia, hazrat
ahlay Hadees aur ahlay
deoband hazrat kie
kitabien dekhie mader
zaihen Mutmin na
howa,Bik akhir aik dost ki
mashwaray se Molana
Ahamd Raza khan ki
kitabien dekhie tou
mera
dil mutmin hogoya tou mein ab bahobi
ahadees ki
sharoue bila jijhak likh
sakta hoon,wakiya
brelvi
hazrat k serkarda Alim Molana Ahmad RAza
khan
shahib ki tehrrieen
shistaaur mazboot
hain,jisay dekh kar yeh
andaza hota hai, k yeh Molvi Ahmad RAza
khan
shahib aik zabardast
Alim-
e-deen aur fikiya hain''
Mahnama Hadi,deoband,
Jamadil Awal 1330
hijri,page 21)
Darulloom deoband ki
shiekh Al Adaab, Jinab
Izaaz Ali Farmtay hain :-
yeh Ahqar yeh baat
tasleem karnay per
majoor
hai k,ise door ander
ager mohqaq aur alm-e-
deen
hai tou wo Molana
Ahmad
Raza khan shahib hain
q k mein nai Molana
Ahmad
Raza khan ko , jisay
hum
aj tak,kafir,mushr ik bidati
kehtay rahay hain,
buhat
wasiee ul nazar aur
buland
kahyal iloo himat alam-e-
deen shahib e fikro
nazar
paya hai, Ap Ahmad
Raza k
daliel Quran-o-sunat se mutsadim nahi, bal kay
am
ahang hain,lihaza mein
ap
ko mashwara
doonga,ager ap ko kise mushkal
maslay
mein,ager ap ko kise
masalay mein kise
kisamki
uljaan dar paish ho,tou ap
breli mein jakar,
Molana
Ahmad Raza khan
shahbi
brelvi se tehqeeq karien''( Reesala Al-
Noor,thana bhoon,
Shawal
al Mukram, 1346 hijri
page
40) . . . . . . .
9) Justice Malik Ghulam
Ali
Shahib farmtay hain:-
Haqeeqt yeh hai k
Molana Ahmad Raza khan
shahib k
barien mein ab tak
hum log
shaht Galt fehmi mein
mubtala thay.iun k baz tasanief aur fatwa k
matalia k bad,ise
natiija
per pohncha hoon,'jou
ilmi
gehri mein iun ki yaha paii
wo buhat kam logo
mein
pai jati hain''aur Ishq-
e-
Khuda aur Rasool (assalato-assal am) iun ki
satar satar se phoot
parta
hai (Aramgani Haram
Page
14 Lakhnuw) . . . . . . .
10) Janab Moen ul deen
Nadwi farmtay hain :-''
Molana Ahmad Raza
khan
shahib brelvi iuse door k
shahib-e-ilem o nazar
ulma musanfeen mein
se
thay, deeni Hasoosan
Fika o Hadees per iun ki
nazar
qasiee aur gehri thie,
Molana Ahmad raza jis
waqt nazr aur tehqeeq
k sath ulma k istafraat k
jawab tehreer farmay
hain, iuse se iun k
jamiyat,ilmi
biseerat ,deeyanat aur
tabie ka pura pura andaza
hota hai,iun k alamana
mehkana fatway
Mohalfat
o Moofaq her Tabka k
Mootlia k lain hain Mahnama Mohraf,
Azam
Garh Shumra
September
1949)
. . . . . . . 11) Jinab Shahbir
Ahmad
Usmani Farmatay
hain :-
Molana Ahamd Raza
khan ko Takfir k jurm mein
Bura
kehna buhat hi bura
hai
hai, q k wo buhat
baray Alam-e-deen aur
Buland
paya k Muhaqiq thay,
Molana Ahmad Raza
khan ki
Rihalat Alam-e-Islam ka
buhat bara saniha
hai,jise
nazar andaz nahi kiya
ja
sakta''( Ma Hadi Deoband
Zul haja 1369 hijri
page 21)
. . . . . . .
12) Jinab Muhammad
Yousaf Banoori k walid shahib
Zakira shah Banori
Farmatay hain:-''Ager
Allah Talla Hindustan
mein
Molana Ahmad Raza khan
brelvi ko paida na
farmatay tou
hindustaan
mein Hanfiyat Hatem
hojati'' . . . . . . .
13) Jinad Abu Al
Hassan Ali
Nadvi Farmatay hain:-
Fika
Hanfi aur iuse ki Jaziat per jou, Molana Ahmad
Raza khan ko aboor
hasil
tha, ise Zamamne mein
iuse ki Nazer nahi milti
14) Modvi Jammat ka Mashoor sahafo Janab
Manoor Al haq farmtay
hain :- Jub hum Imam
Ahmad Raza khan fazle
Brelvi ki kitabo ka
matalia kartay hain tou,tou
masool
hota hai k yeh shakhs
apni
ilmi Fazelat aur apni
abkiriyat ki waja se doosray ulma per
akaila hi
barie hai''(Mahanama
hijaz-e-jadeed , New
Dehli
januray 1989 page 84) . . . . . . .
15) Molana Hiyaat
Muhammad Kosar
Niazi
Farmtay hain :- Molana
Ahmad Raza khan Brelvi k
barien mein ula
deoband k
biynaat per mushtamil
mazmoon ise
Haqeeqat ka aitraaf hai k, Aala
Hazrat
Ahmad raza Brelvi
bilashuba sachay Ashq-
e-
Rasool(assalato - assalaam
aur deen k Yagaana
rozgar
Alam-e aur milat ki
Mohsin
thay''(Roznama JUNG Lahore 3 October
1990 )
. . . . . . .
16) Janab Dr. Israr
Ahmad
(bani tanzeem-e- islam i) Farmatay hain:-''Imam
Ahmad Raza khan
Peechli
sadi ki Mujdeed thay
aur
iun k ilam mein koi shak
nahi''(24 october 2004,
Sialkot Anwar Club
(Confernce 2004)
No comments:
Post a Comment